Soil Respiration and Carbon Balance Under Cover Crop in a no-Till Tropical Fruit Orchard Ariel Freidenreich, et al.

Dec 31, 2021

Introduction

Soil respiration plays a major role in global carbon (C) cycle (Schlesinger and Andrews, 2000; Gougoulias et al., 2014) and is actively related to soil ecosystem productivity. Studies identify conservation or sustainable agriculture as an effective option for enhancing C storage, and in some cases, minimizing CO2 loss from agricultural soil (Martínez-Mena et al., 2021; Jia et al., 2021). Typically, conservation or sustainable agriculture is the culmination of strategies for cultivating crops with minimal inputs, soil disturbances, and implementation of continuous soil cover (mulch) (Hobbs et al., 2008; Zhang and Peng, 2021). Cover cropping is recognized as one of the sustainable agricultural practices that influences soil C balance depending on soil types, land management, and environmental conditions. Ecosystem services provided from cover cropping include organic matter addition, soil structure improvement, weed control, nutrient management, and pollinator attraction, which are especially important in organic, low input systems (Scholberg et al., 2010). Sunn hemp (Crotalaria juncea L.) (SH) and velvet bean (Mucuna pruriens L. DC.) (VB) are leguminous cover crops (CC) with potential to contribute 4 to 14 Mg ha−1 soil organic C (SOC) in tropical climates (Wang et al., 2012; Rosolem et al., 2016).

When CCs are incorporated into a no-till farming system, they have the ability to enhance soil biodiversity and fertility through increasing soil CN fractions and improving aggregate stability (Rigon et al., 2020). While the addition of CCs can be beneficial for soil fertility and crop production, enhanced microbial activity in CC systems can also increase CO2 emission from soil (Sanz-Cobena et al., 2014). In fact, CO2 emissions can even be heightened with the use of legume CCs due to the low C:N ratio of plant tissue produced (Alluvione et al., 2010; Muhammad et al., 2019). Therefore, a soil C balance is needed to elucidate both positive and negative aspects of these CCs in a fruit production setting. This research was conducted in an organically produced carambola (commonly known as starfruit (Averrhoa carambola)) orchard, which are commercially grown only in Florida within the mainland United States.

Traditionally, poultry manure (PM) is commonly applied as fertilizer in organic tropical fruit production systems (Canali et al., 2004; Jones et al., 2020). As over 10 billion kg of poultry litter is produced annually in the United States, composting poultry litter is a useful way to repurpose problematic waste into a nutrient source for crop production (Reddy et al., 2007). Repurposing the waste for agricultural purposes is a sustainable method of adding carbon (C) and nitrogen (N) to soils (Nyakatawa et al., 2001; Reddy et al., 2004), while reducing the risk of N leachate polluting natural systems (Kaiser et al., 2009). Because carambola requires intensive nutrient management during production (both at young and mature stages; Crane, 2016), growing of CCs combined with PM additions could be beneficial to soil health and quality, along with providing economic benefits to the farmers, making this a potentially ideal management strategy for tropical fruit producers.

We selected SH and VB as our study CCs because of their large biomass producing nature (average 14–21 Mg ha−1). These CCs have also proven to accumulate large amounts of SOC and to enhance soil health in South Florida (Wang et al., 2015). However, a comparative analysis of C budget from these 2 CCs has not been studied, specifically, in organic cultivation where SOM is expected to play a major role in the C balance. We also recognized that no literature is available on analyzing the effect of CCs on soil respiration under organic no-till carambola production in the US. Carambola contributes \$3.7 million per year to Florida’s economy with much room for growth (Ballen et al., 2020) with an increasing popularity for the growers since organic avocado (major fruit crop in South Florida) production has been facing serious pest and pathogen problems throughout the last 10–12 years (Menocal et al., 2018). Adding CCs can apply to many tropical fruit grove settings and results from this research may lay the foundation for this practice to be utilized throughout South Florida. Therefore, the specific objectives of this study were to: a) evaluate the emissions of CO2 from SH and VB plots (with and without manure treatments) and b) develop C budgets for both CC plots and elucidate the ability of SH and VB to mitigate CO2 emissions.

Materials and Methods

Site Characteristics and Treatments

A two-season (2018 and 2019) field experiment was conducted in a multi-use certified organic fruit orchard (6.07 ha) located in the Redland Agricultural Area of South Florida, United States. Soil used for this experiment was a sandy loam (73% sand, 17% clay, and 10% slit). At the start of the experiment, the soil had an average pH of 7.6 with 17% SOM content. Soil total carbon and nitrogen were 175 and 8.9 g kg−1, respectively, with soil electrical conductivity at 0.820 dS/m. The soil in the RAA is categorized by the United States Department of Agriculture, National Resource Conservation Service (USDA, NRCS) as Krome Series soil. Prior to carambola being planted, mature sapodilla trees were grown in this area and treated with 5N-3P-2K USDA certified organic composted poultry manure. Average air and soil temperatures were 26.4°C and 28.8°C, respectively, for summer and 21.4°C and 23.7°C, respectively, for winter months. Relative humidity (%) ranged from 81 to 86%; average ∼83% per month and average monthly rainfall ranged from 11 to 35 cm during the wet season and 3–12 cm within the dry season.

TABLE 1. Timeline for agricultural practices followed throughout the experiment.

Sample Collection and Analysis

Soil collars were installed (thin-walled polyvinyl chloride) after initial weeding at each tree (Figure 1) for in situ soil respiration measurements via LI-6400 XT Portable Photosynthesis Meter (Lincoln, Nebraska) with Soil CO2 Flux Chamber attachment (Figure 1C). Soil collars were 10 cm in diameter and 9 cm long, inserted 8 cm into the soil, excluding the litter layer, therefore emission of CO2 from soil is the direct indication of root and microbial respiration of that soil. Gas samples (CO2) were collected every 2 weeks throughout the cover crop growing season (90 days) and once a month there after until the end of the experiment. Gas collection was executed between 11:00 am to 1:00 pm for each sampling event to avoid daytime interferences. Soil and air temperature, soil moisture content, and bulk density, were measured at corresponding soil respiration measurement times. In-field soil temperature and moisture were measured using a STEVENS Hydraprobe (Portland, Oregon), inserted 12.4 cm into the soil. Composite soil samples (0–15 cm depth) were oven dried at 105°C for 24 h to obtain soil moisture content. Bulk density of soils was determined by cylinder method and ranged from 1.2 to 1.3 g cm−3. Rainfall and air temperature data was collected from the Florida Automated Weather Network (FAWN) meteorological station throughout the experiment. Bulk density was used to calculate water filled pore space (WFPS, %) using the formula:

where Ψ is the volumetric water content (%) and TP is the total porosity (%) of the soil. The remaining collected soil samples were oven-dried (30 °C for 48 h), sieved (2 mm), and ground for physicochemical analysis. Total carbon content was measured via dry combustion utilizing a Truspec Carbon/Nitrogen Analyzer (LECO Corporation, St. Joseph, MI). Measured C content of crop biomasses (harvested 90 days after germination, measured with and without manure applications) and dry biomass yields were used to calculate the amount of TC contributed by each cover crop followed the methods described by Wang et al. (2015).

FIGURE 1. Photographic images of (A) established sunn hemp (Crotalaria juncea) crop, (B) established velvet bean (Mucuna pruriens) crop around carambola, (C) in-situ soil CO2 efflux measurement from SH field, and (D) biomass harvesting of velvet bean.

Soil C Balance Calculation

Soil respiration (CO2 emission from soil) is an active indicator of soil health and directly related to soil ecosystem productivity. Soil C balance (SCB) is the measurement of net C contributed by each cover crop and calculated as:

$SCB(kg ha−1)=(TC contribution−TC removed)$

where TC is the total C.

Soil C balances were developed for both cover crops (with and without manure application). Total C contribution was estimated based on the C content (%) in the dry biomass of each CC and the amount of biomass produced by CCs in manure and without manure applied plots. The amount of TC removed was analyzed by calculating the total amount of CO2 produced in the soil (soil respiration) during CC growing seasons.

Statistical Analyses

Statistical analyses were conducted using SPSS (IBM Corp.). IBM SPSS Statistics for Windows (Version 25.0). Armonk, NY: IBM Corp.) and SAS (SAS Institute Inc. 1976. Base SAS® 9.4. Cary, NC: SAS Institute Inc.) software. A one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) was performed to distinguish between the effect of treatment at each sampling time. A two-way repeated ANOVA with Tukey-Kramer post-hoc test was performed to analyze the treatment differences over time at p < 0.05. We used a homogeneity of variance test to compare the variability of CO2 emission data between two seasons. As the variances were homogeneous (p < 0.10), we pooled the datasets and presented the average value for two seasons in this paper.

Results

Emission of CO2 from experimental plots were separated for two timescales: A) CO2 emission from the day after crop germination till the day of CC termination (90 days) and B) CO2 emission from the day after CC termination (or the day manure was applied) to the end of this study (167 days). Average CO2 emission (µmol m−2 s−1) from the control plot (8.22) was similar to SH (8.85) throughout the CC growing seasons (Figure 2). However, CO2 emission from VB plots (10.21) was 23 and 15% higher than control and SH plots, respectively. The amount of CO2-C emission during the last few weeks (55–90 DAG) before CC termination was about 42% higher from both SH and VB plots than initial weeks of CC establishment. This is specifically because higher root respiration during full crop growth stages increased CO2 emission from the soil. Now while comparing the treatments after CC termination, we observed that VB with manure (VBM) plots produced the highest amount of CO2-C followed by SHM (Figure 3).

FIGURE 2. Carbon dioxide (CO2) emission fluxes from carambola orchard during cover crop (sunn hemp, SH and velvet bean, VB) growing season. Both cover crops were terminated 90 days after crop germination (DAG). Variances were homogeneous (p < 0.10); therefore, datasets were pooled and average values for two seasons are presented. Soil, air temperature (0C) and water filled pore space (WFPS%) data are also presented.

FIGURE 3. Carbon dioxide (CO2) emission fluxes from carambola orchard after cover crop (sunn hemp, SH and velvet bean, VB) termination. Manure was applied on the same day after cover crop termination (0 DAT). Variances were homogeneous (p < 0.10); therefore, datasets were pooled and average values for two seasons are presented. Soil, air temperature (0C) and water filled pore space (WFPS%) data are also presented.

Carbon dioxide emission was observed immediately after manure application and high CO2-C emission peaks were observed (as high as 16 μmol m−2 s−1) within first couple of weeks after CC termination (or the manure was applied). In this study, 41% of the total CO2 emission was found within 20 days after crop termination (DAT). Overall, CO2-C emissions from manure applied plots (average 8,030 kg ha−1 season−1) were 17% higher than plots without manure treatment (average 6,870 kg ha−1 season−1) and the emission was significantly higher (p < 0.05) during 20 days after manure application.

Furthermore, we need to consider both positive and negative aspects of CCs in CO2 emission and total C contribution (from crop biomass analysis) during production. Positive C balances were found for both SH and VB (Table 2). An average 13200 kg ha−1 TC was contributed by SH, 33% higher TC than VB and comparing all plots, about 8–10% higher (not significant at p < 0.05) TC contribution was observed from manure applied plots than plots where manure was not applied. The average fraction of emission vs C contribution (CO2-C/TC) was 1.46 times higher in VB plots than SH plots. Higher C emission fraction from VB plots was also an indirect indication of lower C use efficiency by VB cropping system as compared to SH.

TABLE 2. Carbon contribution, % C in crop biomass, and CO2-C emissions from fallow (control) and cover crop (sunn hemp and velvet bean) treated plots in Carambola orchard for two growing seasons in South Florida, United States. Different letters indicate significant difference (p < 0.05) between treatments.

Discussion

Average annual rainfall was 13.25 cm in season one and 11.13 in season two, with relatively higher rainfall observed during July- August (average of 18–24 cm per month) in both years as South Florida experiences a wet summer season and a dry winter season. Rainfall and water filled pore space (WFPS, %; range: 17 to 74, average: 36) did not have any effect on CO2 emission from all plots, however, soil and air temperature had a significant effect (p < 0.10). For instance, higher CO2 emission peaks (at 13, 26, 39, 54 days after germination; DAG) were correlated to higher air and soil temperatures.

Higher soil and air temperature have been reported to increase root and microbial respiration (Huang et al., 2005). Similarly, increased CO2 emissions were observed with higher soil and air temperatures in previous studies conducted in the sub-tropical US (Wang et al., 2013; Dattamudi et al., 2019; Ray et al., 2020). Daily average CO2-C emission (94 kg ha−1) during CC growing season from our experiment (Figure 2) corroborate well with other CC studies amended with organic manure (Ray et al., 2020). However, our study noted increased CO2 emission (3–4 times higher) when compared to other studies conducted in mineral soils in the same agroclimatic region (Tian et al., 2015; Dattamudi et al., 2019). This comparative analysis suggests that OM played a significant role (our soil had 17% OM) in increasing soil microbial activity and root respiration during crop production. This can be compared to a recent study in which Bosco et al. (2019) reported that cumulative and daily CO2 emissions from organic systems were higher than an integrated cropping system for vegetable production. Additionally, lower CO2-C emissions were observed from fallow (control) plots than CC treatments. This result was likely caused by lower root respiration from those plots. Crop biomass production and ground cover of SH was higher than VB, which resulted in lower soil temperature during SH production, and subsequently, a lower CO2 emission from soil during the CC growing season. Moreover, the quality and quantity of harvested CC biomass can also have an effect on soil respiration rates (Nilahyane et al., 2020), a possible factor impacting our results.

Furthermore, prior findings have supported that application of chemical fertilizers have little to no effect on CO2 emission from mineral soils (Dattamudi et al., 2019; Sistani et al., 2019). In our study, CO2-C emissions from manure applied plots was higher than those that were not treated with PM, specifically within the first 20 days of PM application. The spike in CO2 emission from manure applied plots possibly resulted from higher microbial degradation of 17% SOM along with increased root respiration in our soil. Average C:N ratio (mol:mol) of SH and VB leaf biomass were in the range of 12:1 to 17:1, similar to previous studies (Valenzuela and Smith, 2002). A C:N ratio lower than 15:1 indicates a net N mineralization in the soil (Hagemann et al., 2016) which likely resulted in higher microbial activity in manure and CC treated plots. Therefore, CO2 emission peaks were observed immediately after manure was applied (increased microbial activity and root respiration) in both crops. Large amounts of nutrients from CC biomass are often released 30–60 days after incorporation into the soil, which is highly dependent on the C:N ratio of the CC species (Lynch et al., 2016). As a result, a few CO2 emission peaks observed during 40–75 DAT were likely caused by an increased nutrient release in the second month after CC termination. Our findings indicate that soil respiration (and CO2 emission) can be influenced by the addition of macro and micronutrients if abundant food sources (SOM) are present for the microbial community. Interestingly, unlike the CC growing seasons, soil and air temperatures had very little effects on CO2 emissions after CC termination except for few relatively higher peaks (74 and 141 DAT) that corresponded to higher temperatures.

Higher TC contribution by SH (with and without manure) indicates that SH could be a stronger CC candidate for contributing C in organic rich soil than VB. In a study conducted in similar agroclimatic zone, Wang et al. (2012) found lower TC contribution by SH (8.71 Mg ha−1) and VB (4.73 Mg ha−1) monocultures in mineral soil, confirming that organic matter plays a major role in biomass production and subsequently TC contribution (our soil has 17% SOM) in soil. Soils in manure applied plots had higher TC regardless of the type of cover crop. It should be noted that average C content of the PM was 33.76 ± 0.29%, which would amount to 561 ± 67 kg ha−1 of TC contribution, which could account for higher TC contribution in manure applied plots. Interestingly, total C contribution by SH was greater than VB, but CO2 emission from VB was higher than SH plots. This indicates that C contributed by VB was likely in labile form which stimulated higher microbial activities and subsequently greater CO2 emissions. Another possible explanation could be the rate of crop biomass decomposition from SH and VB plots. Higher crop residue decomposition was reported to increase soil CO2 emission (Campos et al., 2011). We did not measure the biomass decomposition rate for SH and VB, but in a recent study conducted in tropical area of Brazil, Xavier et al. (2017) categorized SH as a cover crop with great resistance to decomposition, while VB was categorized as intermediate resistance.

We understand that the soil C balance developed in this study was only from two crop growing seasons, and a long-term field experiment would be more suitable to determine the CC contribution of soil C dynamics. However, in comparing the short-duration effectiveness of SH and VB in contributing/accumulating TC in the soil and influencing CO2 emission, our result suggest that SH has greater potential to reduce CO2 emissions from the soil. When sufficient C present in the soil, the addition of N and other nutrients combined with meteorological parameters can significantly influence soil respiration.

Data Availability Statement

The original contributions presented in the study are included in the article/Supplementary Material, further inquiries can be directed to the corresponding author.

Author Contributions

AF, YL, and KJ conceived and planned the experiment. AF carried out the experiment, processed the experimental data, and performed field/laboratory analysis. All authors contributed to the interpretation of the results. SD took the lead in writing the manuscript, statistical analysis, and creating figures. All authors provided critical feedback and input that helped shape the research, analysis, and manuscript. KJ supervised the work and provided funding for the project.

Funding

Funding sources for this project: USDA-NIFA-NNF 2015-38420-23702, Florida International University Tropics and the Susan S. Levine Trust, and the Florida International University Graduate School Doctoral Evidence Acquisition and Dissertation Year Fellowships.

Conflict of Interest

The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.

Publisher’s Note

All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article, or claim that may be made by its manufacturer, is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.

Acknowledgments

We would like to acknowledge Marc Ellenby and family for supplying LNB Groves as the field site for this experiment. We also thank Dr. Steven Oberbauer for technical instrumentation support and guidance.