Enamel demineralization is one of the most common dental problems which could appear as white spot lesions (WSLs) in the early stage and even progress into cavities if effective interventions are not taken in time (Julien et al., 2013). In the normal oral environment, hydroxyapatite on the enamel surface contacts saliva and maintains the balance of dissolution and redeposition (Sollböhmer et al., 1995; Featherstone, 2004), hydroxyapatite could be dissolved into calcium and phosphorus ions while calcium and phosphorus ions in saliva could crystallize directionally and orderly, forming the enamel-like hydroxyapatite structure on the surface of the enamel (Dorozhkin, 1997). When the oral hygiene condition is poor, plaque biofilms form and adhere onto the enamel surface decomposing sugars, producing organic acids, and resulting in an acidic pH environment around the enamel. Under this circumstance, the dissolution-redeposition balance of hydroxyapatite is broken. The dissolution of hydroxyapatite occurs faster than the deposition of calcium and phosphorus ions, which eventually leads to the occurrence of enamel demineralization.

Based on the etiology of enamel demineralization, the strategies to prevent or treat enamel demineralization include: 1) Using antibacterial agents such as mouthwash or toothpaste containing antibacterial drugs (Hefti and Huber, 1987; Afennich et al., 2011; Hossainian et al., 2011; Rösing et al., 2017; Ahmed et al., 2019; Bijle et al., 2019; Guven et al., 2019; Karadağlıoğlu et al., 2019; Shang et al., 2020) which could inhibit the accumulation and adhesion of cariogenic bacteria on the enamel surface to reduce the acid production from plaque biofilms; 2) Using fluorinated agents such as fluoride mouthwash (Chow et al., 2000; Songsiripradubboon et al., 2014; Larsson et al., 2020) and fluoride varnish (Gontijo et al., 2007; Marinho, 2009; Perrini et al., 2016), which could not only inhibit cariogenic bacteria but release fluorine, co-crystallize with calcium and phosphorus ions to form fluorapatite on the enamel surface (Margolis and Murphy, 1986; Zandim-Barcelos et al., 2011).

In addition to the above strategies, the enamel biomimetic remineralization strategy, which bases on the natural enamel crystallization process (Cölfen and Mann, 2003), is being studied extensively due to its biomimetic mineralization capability (Chen et al., 2015; Wang et al., 2017). According to the nonclassical crystallization theory, the crystallization processes of natural enamel could be interpreted as the following steps: 1) Calcium and phosphorus ions aggregating together to form amorphous calcium phosphate (ACP); 2) Amelogenin stabilizing ACP into clusters; 3) ACP then directionally arranging to form bundles of hydroxyapatite, then gradually forming enamel crystal, and finally forming enamel prism (Beniash et al., 2009; Yang et al., 2010; Kwak et al., 2016). To mimic the crystallization process of natural enamel and to achieve remineralization of demineralized enamel, ACP needs to be stabilized and then crystallizes directionally and orderly to form the enamel-like hydroxyapatite. In this review, we mainly focused on how different agents stabilize ACP and their remineralization effects on enamel demineralization.

Amelogenin and its Analogs

Amelogenin (Amel) plays an important role in the formation of natural enamel (Wright et al., 2011; Moradian-Oldak, 2012; Ruan and Moradian-Oldak, 2015). Amelogenin could interact with calcium and phosphorus ions through the tyrosine enrichment segment on its N-terminal and stabilize calcium and phosphorus ions to an amorphous state (Figure 1A). The C-terminal of Amel could guide ACP to crystallize into hydroxyapatite directionally (Tsiourvas et al., 2015). There are studies using chitosan to load amelogenin and form the chitosan-amelogenin gel (CS-Amel gel) and using this gel system for reconstruction of demineralized enamel. The CS-Amel gel could stabilize calcium and phosphorus ions into ACP, guide ACP to form the enamel-like crystals which bind closely with natural enamel crystals (Ruan et al., 2013; Ruan et al., 2014). In addition to the direct application of amelogenin, there are studies focused on the remineralization effect of amelogenin analogs. Zhong et al., 2021 self-assembled the N-terminal tyrosine segment of amelogenin to form leucine-rich amelogenin peptide (LRAP) and evaluated the stabilizing and directional guiding abilities of LRAP to calcium and phosphorus ions in mineralizing solutions. LRAP could stabilize calcium and phosphorus ions into ACP effectively and guide ACP to grow along its C-axis into bundles of hydroxyapatite crystals. Wang combined a phase conversion lyase (PTL) which mimics the function of the N-terminal of amelogenin with a synthetic peptide chain which has the function of the C-terminal of amelogenin to form amyloid amelogenin analog (PTL/C-AMG) (Wang Y et al., 2020). The PTL/C-AMG could combine calcium and phosphorus ions to form hydroxyapatite and promote the extension growth of hydroxyapatite crystals on the surface of natural enamel and eventually forms a highly ordered hydroxyapatite structure with mechanical properties similar to that of natural enamel. Lv and colleagues synthesized a short-chain polypeptide (QP5) based on the amino sequence of amelogenin and proved the stabilizing ability of QP5 to calcium and phosphorus ions. They verified the remineralization ability of QP5 to initial enamel demineralization in an in vitro enamel demineralization model and further confirmed its remineralization ability and potential for clinical transformation in a rat caries model (Lv et al., 2015; Han et al., 2017).

FIGURE 1. Schematic diagram of ACP stabilizers and how they stabilize the ACP. (A) Amelogenin stabilizes calcium and phosphorus ions with its N-terminal; (B) Casein phosphopeptides stabilize calcium and phosphorus ions with the -Ser(P)- Ser(P)- Ser(P)-Glu-Glu- sequence; (C) Chitosan derivatives stabilize calcium and phosphorus ions with functional groups; (D) Carboxymethylated poly-amidoamine (PAMAM) stabilizes calcium and phosphorus ions with carboxyl groups; (E) Polyelectrolytes stabilize calcium and phosphorus ions with functional groups.

Casein Phosphopeptides

Casein phosphopeptides (CPP) are casein extracts from milk which could markedly increase the apparent solubility of calcium phosphate ions by forming ACP (Reeves and Latour, 1958). Researchers found that the main active sequence of CPP, the phosphoserine – glutamate cluster (-Ser(P)- Ser(P)- Ser(P)-Glu-Glu-), could stabilize calcium and phosphate ions and form the CPP stabilized ACP complex (CPP-ACP) (Adamson and Reynolds, 1996) to avoid the spontaneously crystallizing, phase conversing and precipitating of calcium and phosphorus ion (Shen et al., 2001) (Figure 1B). Reynolds soaked artificially demineralized enamel in CPP-ACP solution and found that CPP-ACP could remineralize the subsurface demineralization of enamel effectively. The mechanism may be that CPP can maintain a high concentration of calcium and phosphorus ions in the solution to infiltrate into the subsurface lesion area to achieve efficient enamel remineralization (Reynolds, 1997). The team further validated the preventive effect of CPP-ACP on enamel demineralization in a rat caries model (Reynolds et al., 1995). With the U.S. Food and Drug Administration and other regulatory agencies confirming the biosafety of CPP-ACP (Cochrane et al., 2010), CPP-ACP is added into oral health care products such as Tooth Mousse (GC, Tokyo, Japan) (Rees et al., 2007) and Tooth Mousse Plus (CPP-ACPF, GC, Tokyo, Japan) (Hamba et al., 2011; Bataineh et al., 2017; Olgen et al., 2021). These agents have been gradually used in clinical practice and have been studied in a number of clinical trials (Sitthisettapong et al., 2015; Güçlü et al., 2016; Munjal et al., 2016; Thierens et al., 2019). However, the remineralization ability of CPP-ACP and CPP-ACPF for WSLs remains unknown. Researchers suggested that CPP-ACP and CPP-ACPF may have the ability to prevent and treat WSLs, but their effects are not significantly greater than using fluoride agent alone (Pithon et al., 2019; Wang D et al., 2020). In addition, casein related allergy in certain populations also limits the clinical use of CPP-ACP and CPP-ACPF.


In addition to the aforementioned amelogenin and its analogs and CPP, some kinds of polymers can also stabilize calcium and phosphate ions, including chitosan derivatives, poly-amidoamine and polyelectrolytes.

Chitosan Derivatives

Chitosan derivatives, such as carboxymethyl chitosan (CMC) and phosphorylated chitosan (Pchi) could bind calcium ions through chelation reaction of carboxyl groups and calcium ions and then bind phosphate ions to form ACP (Figure 1C). The recrystallization of demineralization enamel is realized by the ordered crystallization of ACP to form enamel-like hydroxyapatite crystals (Zhang et al., 2014; Zhang et al., 2018). Zhu combined carboxymethyl chitosan (CMC) and lysozyme (LYZ) to stabilize ACP and formed the CMC/LYZ-ACP nano-gel, which can regenerate prism-like remineralized enamel layer on the surface of eroded enamel to realize the remineralization (Zhu et al., 2021). Song successively added CaCl2 and K2HPO4 into Pchi solution to construct the Pchi-ACP nano-complex. X-ray diffraction and selective electron diffraction results confirmed the amorphous state of the nano-complex. And the results of scanning electron microscopy and micro-CT proved that the Pchi-ACP nano-complex could realize the remineralization of demineralized enamel (Song et al., 2021).


Poly-amidoamine (PAMAM) was first synthesized by Tomalia in the 1980s (Tomalia et al., 1985). PAMAM contains a large number of amide groups that have the similar function to peptide bonds so that PAMAM could simulate functions of a variety of proteins and peptides (Svenson and Tomalia, 2012). PAMAM can have mineralization property through the modification of carboxyl groups. The carboxyl-modified PAMAM (PAMAM-COOH) could combine calcium ions through carboxyl groups and further attract phosphate ions to stabilize calcium and phosphate ions into ACP (Khopade et al., 2002; Zhou et al., 2007; Zhou et al., 2013) (Figure 1D). ACP could form enamel-like hydroxyapatite orderly on the surface of demineralized enamel through the crystallization guidance of PAMAM-COOH (Chen et al., 2013). Another study found that PAMAM-COOH can induce calcium and phosphorus ions to grow and crystallize along the z-axis on the surface of demineralized enamel, and the microhardness of the remineralized enamel is comparable to that of the natural enamel (Chen M et al., 2014).


Polyelectrolytes are a class of polymorphs with ionizable units, which could ionize into charged polymorphs and counter-ions with opposite charge in aqueous solution (Koetz and Kosmella, 2007) such as polyacrylic acid (PAA), polyallylamine (PAH), polyaspartic acid (PASP), et al. PAA has rich carboxyl groups to combine with calcium ions to form the -COO/Ca2+ structure (Huang et al., 2008), so that PAA can stabilize ACP (Gower, 2008; Dey et al., 2010) (Figure 1E). Qi added calcium and phosphorus ions into the PAA solution to construct the PAA-ACP complex and verified the stability of the PAA-ACP complex by solution turbidity analysis and dynamic light scattering. Scanning electron microscopy, transmission electron microscopy, infrared spectroscopy and X-ray diffraction analyses proved the remineralization ability of PAA-ACP (Qi et al., 2018). Our group used PAA to stabilize amorphous calcium phosphate, and then loaded PAA-ACP with aminoated mesoporous silicon nanoparticle (aMSN) to form the [email protected] delivery system. The [email protected] was proved to have the ability to promote enamel remineralization and surface microhardness analysis and X-ray diffraction analysis showed that the remineralization layer induced by [email protected] had comparable mechanical property and crystal texture to natural enamel (Hua et al., 2020). PAA-ACP could also act as a dental adhesive filler to endow adhesives with enamel remineralization ability (Wang et al., 2018). Other polyelectrolytes like polyallylamine (Niu et al., 2017; Yang et al., 2017), polyaspartic acid (Zhou, et al., 2021), polyglutamic acid (Sikirić, et al., 2009; Terauchi, et al., 2019) could alsostabilize calcium and phosphorus ions but the treatment or prevention effect of these polyelectrolyte-stabilized ACPs for enamel demineralization remains to be further investigated.

ACP Particles

As a kind of amorphous substance, ACP is easy to spontaneously transform into apatite crystal in an aqueous solution from the thermodynamics point of view (Eanes et al., 1965; Chow et al., 1998). Therefore, in addition to the application of stabilizers to stabilize ACP in an amorphous state, another way to stabilize ACP is to store the prepared ACP in an anhydrous dry granular state to form ACP particles. Since the 1990s, ACP particle has been gradually used as a bioactive additive in the studies of tooth remineralization (Skrtic and Eanes, 1996). ACP particle could act as a bioactive filler of dental filling resin to endow the filling resin with the ability of continuous releasing of calcium and phosphorus ions to promote the formation of hydroxyapatite (Skrtic et al., 2004). However, the uncontrollable agglomeration of ACP particles in the resin affects the mechanical properties of resin such as bonding strength and bending strength, so that ACP particles are only suitable for materials with low requirements on mechanical properties, such as pit and fissure sealant (Skrtic et al., 2004; Dunn, 2007). In 2011, Xu synthesized nano ACP (NACP) by spray drying method for the first time and mixed it into dental resin as filler. The NACP modified dental resin could release calcium and phosphorus ions in an acidic environment, and the mechanical properties of the resin are even better than commercial dental resin materials (Xu et al., 2011). Since then, a large number of studies added NACP to dental materials such as orthodontic bonding resins, sealants, resin-modified glass ions and other materials, and verified their calcium and phosphorus ion release ability and enamel remineralization ability (Chen C et al., 2014; Ma et al., 2017; Liu et al., 2018; Xie et al., 2019; Gao et al., 2020; Ibrahim et al., 2020).

ACP Agents Versus Other Remineralization Agents

In addition to ACP agents, there are many other enamel remineralization agents such as fluorine containing agents, hydroxyapatite preparations and tricalcium phosphate. In vitro and in vivo studies have been conducted to compare the remineralization performance of ACP agents and other agents (Table 1). However, the conclusion varied among these studies. Some studies found that ACP agents have better remineralization effect than other agents, while others suggested that the remineralization effect of ACP agents is similar to or no better than other agents. Whether the ACP agents have better remineralization properties than other agents needs to be further investigated in the future research.

TABLE 1. Comparison of the remineralization performance of ACP agents with other products.


ACP agents have outstanding preventive and therapeutic capacity to enamel demineralization due to their ability to form the enamel-like hydroxyapatite on the surface of demineralized enamel (Kwak et al., 2016). However, Since ACP is easy to agglomerate and is unstable in an aqueous solution (Chow et al., 1998), the main challenge in applying the ACP for enamel remineralization is its stabilization. Many different materials that could stabilize calcium and phosphorus ions, including amelogenin and its analogs (Tsiourvas et al., 2015; Wang Y et al., 2020), casein phosphopeptides (Cross et al., 2005), polymers like chitosan derivatives (Zhu et al., 2021), carboxymethylated PAMAM (Chen et al., 2013) and polyelectrolytes (Hua et al., 2020), have been used in studies to stabilize calcium and phosphorus ions into ACP. Another strategy is to store the ACP in a water-free state so that ACP particles and NACP particles are formed (Betts et al., 1975; Xu et al., 2011). The remineralization abilities of these ACP agents have been confirmed in previous studies. However, except for CPP-ACP and CPP-ACPF which has been commercialized (Reise et al., 2021), most of the other ACP agents are still at in vitro experimental stage. Tt is still uncertain whether these ACP agents can achieve the remineralization of demineralized enamel in vivo. In addition, most of the studies evaluated the remineralization ability of ACP agents by measuring the hardness recovery of demineralized enamel (Gokkaya et al., 2020), observing the mineral deposition on demineralized enamel (Hua et al., 2020), or measuring the lesion depth (Soares-Yoshikawa et al., 2021). None of the above-mentioned evaluation methods can directly confirm whether ACP agents could form the enamel-like hydroxyapatite. The biomimetic remineralization ability of ACP agents needs further investigation. To further promote the translation of ACP agents into clinical application, basic studies with adequate evaluation methods as well as relevant in vivo studies are still needed. In addition, whether ACP agents have better remineralization effects compared to other agents remains to be further explored.

ACP complexes are in the amorphous state of the liquid phase (Chen et al., 2013; Niu et al., 2017; Qi et al., 2018; Song et al., 2021), and ACP particles (Skrtic et al., 2004; Xu et al., 2011) are solid powders. Neither the liquid nor the solid form is convenient for storage and direct application in the oral environment. Studies has been conducted to address the storage and application challenges of ACP agents:

1) Mouthwash. Studies used carriers like chitosan (Ruan et al., 2013) and carboxymethyl chitosan (Zhu et al., 2021) to load ACP agents and these delivery systems can be applied in the oral environment in the form of mouthwash.

2) Toothpaste and tooth desensitizer. Another form of application of the ACP agents is to make them into pastes. Our group used mesoporous silicon nanoparticles to load ACP agents to achieve the enrichment and storage of ACP and this delivery system can be applied as the filler of toothpaste (Hua et al., 2020). CPP-ACP agents can be used as desensitizers in the form of pastes (Pei et al., 2013; Chandavarkar and Ram, 2015; Yang et al., 2018).

3) Resin product. Particulate forms of ACP have been incorporated into resin products, like adhesives (Wang et al., 2018), pit and fissure sealants (Utneja et al., 2018), varnishes (Schemehorn et al., 2011) to achieve convenient applications that do not depend on patient compliance.

Mouthwash form of the ACP agent is convenient to use, but the relatively low concentration of ACP and its inability to persist on the enamel surface for long periods lead to the limited effectiveness of ACP agents to enamel remineralization. The paste-like application form could effectively enhance the concentration of ACP and could maintain a high concentration of ACP on the enamel surface during application, but like mouthwash, it still has a short duration of hydroxyapatite formation due to the effect of saliva flushing. ACP agents modified resin products can release ACP on the enamel surface for a long period thus achieving the long-term prevention or treatment of enamel demineralization. However, the effect of ACP agent incorporation on the performance of these products like mechanical performance and biocompatibility needs further exploration. And the long-term stability of the ACP release from these products should be considered in future studies.


Herein we summarize the strategies of stabilizing ACP. Calcium and phosphorus ions can be stabilized to the ACP state using a variety of methods, but the preventive and therapeutic effects of these ACP agents on enamel demineralization still await further investigation. There are three main forms of storage and application of ACP agents, namely mouthwash, toothpaste/tooth desensitizer, resin product. However, due to the shortcomings of the above-mentioned forms of ACP agents, more easy-to-use and long-lasting forms of ACP agents remain to be further explored.

Author Contributions

JY drafted the manuscript. HY and TL revised the manuscript. FH and HH designed the work and revised the manuscript. All authors approved the final version to be published.


This work was financially supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (No. 81901044), Chinese Stomatological Association COS Basic Research Fund (No. COS-B2021-08), and Wuhan Young and Middle-aged Medical Talents Training Program (No. (2019)87).

Conflict of Interest

The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.

Publisher’s Note

All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article, or claim that may be made by its manufacturer, is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.



This article is autogenerated using RSS feeds and has not been created or edited by OA JF.

Click here for Source link (